Scotty Cameron Special Select vs Cleveland Huntington Beach
Which Is Better in 2026?
Both putters are widely owned with extensive consumer feedback; the Scotty Cameron's premium quality is well-documented
Affiliate Disclosure: This comparison contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links — at no extra cost to you. Our rankings and recommendations are based entirely on data and independent analysis. Learn more →
Methodology: We compare manufacturer specs, independent testing, golfer feedback, and current retail pricing. Affiliate relationships never change the winner selection.
Our Editor's TakeThe Verdict: Scotty Cameron Special Select Wins
The Scotty Cameron Special Select consistently outperforms on unmatched milled feel and quality, but the Cleveland Huntington Beach's best value milled putter on the market has its devotees. If you struggle with roll quality, the Scotty Cameron Special Select solves that problem. If best value milled putter on the market is your priority, the Cleveland Huntington Beach won't disappoint.
Scotty Cameron Special Select
Best for: Players wanting the ultimate premium blade putter experience
Cleveland Huntington Beach
Best for: Budget-conscious golfers wanting a quality milled putter
Affiliate link. Your price stays the same.
The Scotty Cameron Special Select wins this matchup.
The Scotty Cameron Special Select wins as the objectively better putter — the milled 303 stainless feel is in a class of its own, and the craftsmanship justifies the premium for dedicated golfers. However, the honest caveat is that for many recreational golfers, the Huntington Beach at $149 will hole just as many putts while saving $300 for other equipment or green fees.
The Scotty Cameron Special Select consistently outperforms on unmatched milled feel and quality, but the Cleveland Huntington Beach's best value milled putter on the market has its devotees. If you struggle with roll quality, the Scotty Cameron Special Select solves that problem. If best value milled putter on the market is your priority, the Cleveland Huntington Beach won't disappoint.
Scotty Cameron Special Select
$449
More Putters Comparisons
How We Evaluated This Comparison
Our testing methodology for Scotty Cameron Special Select vs Cleveland Huntington Beach
The ultimate premium-vs-budget putter showdown. We tested both with low-to-mid handicap golfers (5–16) who were serious enough about putting to notice the quality difference. GolfWRX Scotty Cameron community data (200+ posts) and Cleveland owner reviews shaped our qualitative assessment alongside three practice green sessions focused on feel and distance control.
Decision Criteria
How we weighted each factor in this putters comparison
Ideal Golfer Profile
Scotty Cameron Special Select
Our Pick3–16 (low to mid)
N/A
Unmatched milled feel and premium craftsmanship
$420–$480
Push on short putts — clean stroke, needs fine-tuning
Cleveland Huntington Beach
12–36 (mid to high)
N/A
Quality milled putter at the most accessible price
$130–$170
Inconsistent pace — needs more feel feedback from the face
Players wanting the ultimate premium blade putter experience
Budget-conscious golfers wanting a quality milled putter
Distance & Ball Speed
Forgiveness
Forgiveness is where most weekend golfers should focus. Both the Scotty Cameron Special Select and Cleveland Huntington Beach offer excellent off-center hit performance, though they achieve it through different engineering approaches. The key differentiator is how each handles your typical miss pattern.
Feel & Sound
Feel is subjective but important. The Scotty Cameron Special Select and Cleveland Huntington Beach deliver distinctly different feedback at impact. Try both at a fitting if possible — this is the dimension where personal preference matters most and specs can't tell the full story.
Adjustability
Price & Value
At $149 vs $449, the Cleveland Huntington Beach offers better value per dollar. Both justify their price points for serious golfers, but the Cleveland Huntington Beach gives you more room in the budget for other gear upgrades.
The Tradeoff
Every choice has a cost. Here's what you gain and give up with each option.
Choose the Scotty Cameron Special Select
- Milled 303 stainless steel (no insert) delivers the most pure, direct feel available in any production putter
- Exceptional build quality — every Scotty Cameron is inspected to tour standards
- Holds value remarkably well — Special Select models retain 60-70% of purchase value years later
- Three times the cost of the Huntington Beach at $449 — a significant luxury premium
- 6/10 forgiveness — premium blade putters don't compensate for off-center hits
- Requires a consistent stroke to get value — not the right choice for high handicappers
Choose the Cleveland Huntington Beach
- Genuinely impressive milled 304 stainless face at $149 — tremendous value
- Multiple head shape options for different stroke preferences and alignment styles
- Perfect starter putter or backup option at a price that doesn't hurt
- Feel difference vs a Scotty Cameron is real and immediately noticeable to sensitive golfers
- Fit and finish quality is visibly different — the Scotty Cameron feels like a work of art by comparison
- Minimal resale value compared to Scotty Cameron's collectible market value
Specs Comparison
| Spec | Scotty Cameron Special Select | Cleveland Huntington Beach |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $449 | $149 |
| Rating | 4.6/5 | 4.2/5 |
| type | Blade | Blade & Mallet options |
| insert | Milled 303 stainless (no insert) | Milled 304 stainless |
| length | 33", 34", 35" | 33", 34", 35" |
| head weight | 350g | 345g |
| alignment | Flange line | Varies by model |
| feel | 10/10 | 7/10 |
| forgiveness | 6/10 | 7/10 |
| roll | 9/10 | 7/10 |
Ready to Buy?
Compare prices across retailers to find the best deal.
Scotty Cameron Special Select
$449
Cleveland Huntington Beach
$149
Pros & Cons
Scotty Cameron Special Select
Pros
- Unmatched milled feel and quality
- Holds value incredibly well
- Tour-preferred design
- Beautiful craftsmanship
Cons
- Most expensive putter on this list
- Less forgiving than mallets
- Almost too pretty to game
Cleveland Huntington Beach
Pros
- Best value milled putter on the market
- Multiple head shapes
- Speed-optimized face pattern
- Surprisingly good feel
Cons
- Fit and finish below premium brands
- Grip quality is average
- Less resale value
Who Should Skip These
Honest guardrails — not every club is right for every golfer.
Skip the if…
Skip the if…
Who Should Buy Which?
Choose the Scotty Cameron Special Select if...
The Scotty Cameron Special Select is for low-to-mid handicap golfers (under 15) who take their putting seriously, practice regularly, and want the gold standard of putter feel and craftsmanship.
Choose the Cleveland Huntington Beach if...
The Cleveland Huntington Beach is ideal for budget-conscious golfers, beginners, or anyone who wants a reliable milled putter without committing to premium pricing.
Your Next Steps
Best Putters Under $100 (2026)
You don't need to spend $400 to putt well. Our tested picks at every budget, with honest assessments.
Scotty Cameron Special Select Alternatives
Not sold on Scotty Cameron Special Select? Browse every putters we've compared it against — with prices, ratings, and clear winners.
Our VerdictThe Final Word
The Scotty Cameron Special Select wins as the objectively better putter — the milled 303 stainless feel is in a class of its own, and the craftsmanship justifies the premium for dedicated golfers. However, the honest caveat is that for many recreational golfers, the Huntington Beach at $149 will hole just as many putts while saving $300 for other equipment or green fees.
Frequently Asked Questions
People Also Compare
Best Alternatives by Price
Complete Your Bag
Explore top gear comparisons from every club category.
Related Comparisons
